Tuesday, June 15, 2004


a Zionist's loving heart

I've been meaning to write on Jeffrey Goldberg's New Yorker article Among the Settlers for several weeks now, and finally, given two op-eds regarding the Goldberg article that I've come across in the past two days, I now have the impetus to do so. Let me first say that Goldberg's article was at the same time satisfying and unsatisfying to read. It really exposed the mania and extremism of some of the Israeli settlers in a way that I have never seen in a widely read mainstream publication like The New Yorker. On the other hand, it also manages to maintain an undeniable pro-Israel bias. Even in an article about the settlers, much time is spent profiling Hamas leaders, blaming Yasser Arafat for the end of the peace process, and criticizing Palestinian society as a culture which breeds terrorists. This must be what Richard Cohen means when he writes in his Washington Post op-ed today, "Goldberg has written a good article about some ugly facts -- and done so with a reporter's keen eye, but also with a Zionist's loving heart." Cohen, at least, openly states his pro-Israel position. "But the issue for me is not what is good for the Palestinians -- I wish them a state of their own and also all the happiness in the world -- but what is good for Israel," Cohen writes, and then goes on to play down the extremism that Goldberg was honest enough to expose in his article. Of the settlers, Cohen writes:
Some of what the Jewish settlers told Goldberg is disturbing. Many of them have a contemptuous, virtually racist, view of their Arab neighbors. They are wedded to the literal word of the Bible while much of Judaism is not, and while they by no means share the Islamic radicals' yen for martyrdom -- and they do not approve of the killing of innocents -- they are quite willing to die for their beliefs. Okay.
First of all, many of them do not have a virtually racist view of their Arab neighbors. There is nothing virtual about it. They have racist views. Second of all, some of them definitely approve of the killing of innocents (not innocents in their world view, where standing in the way of Jewish reclamation of Biblical lands precludes the Palestinians from innocence, but innocents in the rest of the world's eyes). Allow me to quote some passages from Goldberg's article that Cohen maybe skimmed over.
Across from Hadassah House is a school for Arab girls, called Córdoba, after the once-Muslim Spanish city. On one of its doors someone had drawn a blue Star of David. On another door a yellowing bumper sticker read, “Dr. Goldstein Cures the Ills of Israel.” The reference is to Baruch Goldstein, a physician from Brooklyn, who, in 1994, killed twenty-nine Muslims when they were praying in the Tomb of the Patriarchs, just down the road. Across the closed door of a Palestinian shop someone had written, in English, “Arabs Are Sand Niggers.”
The Cohen house is cramped and dark, and there are few toys. On one wall hangs a framed photograph of Meir Kahane, the zealot rabbi from Brooklyn, who advocated the expulsion of all Arabs from Israel. Behind a stone pillar hangs a photograph of Baruch Goldstein, with the inscription “The Saint Dr. Goldstein.”
I told him [Rabbi Moshe Levinger] that the police seemed uneasy about his presence in the tomb, and I asked whether they were worried that he would lash out at the Palestinians.

“The Arabs know to behave like good boys around us,” he said.
In 1988, Levinger killed a Palestinian shoe-store owner in Hebron. Levinger told the police that he was defending himself from a group of stone throwers. He served thirteen weeks in an Israeli jail for the killing. He told me once, “I’m not happy when any living creature dies—an Arab, a fly, a donkey.”
Moshe Feiglin, a Likud activist who lives in a West Bank settlement and heads the Jewish Leadership bloc within the Party—he controls nearly a hundred and fifty of the Likud central committee’s three thousand members—believes that the Bible, interpreted literally, should form the basis of Israel’s legal system. “Why should non-Jews have a say in the policy of a Jewish state?” Feiglin said to me. “For two thousand years, Jews dreamed of a Jewish state, not a democratic state. Democracy should serve the values of the state, not destroy them.” In any case, Feiglin said, “You can’t teach a monkey to speak and you can’t teach an Arab to be democratic. You’re dealing with a culture of thieves and robbers. Muhammad, their prophet, was a robber and a killer and a liar. The Arab destroys everything he touches.”
I asked who was destroying the olive trees. The destruction of fruit-giving trees, even those belonging to an enemy, is considered a grave sin in Judaism. But the only subject that concerned [Yehuda] Liebman was Joseph’s Tomb.

“What is an olive tree compared to the burial place of Joseph, the son of Jacob?” he said.

To the farmer who supports his family with the tree, I said, the tree is important.

“But the farmer is an Arab,” Liebman replied. “He shouldn’t be here at all. All this land is Jewish land. It is meant for the Jews by God Himself.”
As we drove, [Moshe] Saperstein pointed to the spot on the road where the attack had taken place. “Here’s where I tried to run over the peace-loving Muslim,” he said. Sometimes, he told me, he gets the feeling that “Ahmed is trying to kill me.” Saperstein refers to Arabs generically as “Ahmed.”

Just before we reached the fortified entrance to the Gush Katif bloc, we passed the ramshackle Bedouin village of Muwassi. “They like to live like pigs in shit,” Saperstein said. I disagreed, vehemently, and he said, “I’m sorry, that’s politically incorrect. ‘They have a different cultural aesthetic.’ Is that what I’m supposed to say?”
Virtually racist? Virtually? Are you kidding me? And not approving of the killing of innocents? Only the veneration of Baruch Goldstein, who killed 29 praying Muslims. Fortunately, Goldberg is a much better journalist than Cohen. Still, that doesn't mean that I find his arguments all that persuasive. Despite his concern over the settlements, Goldberg fundamentally blames the Palestinians for their own situation, holds Arafat responsible for the lack of peace, and derides the efforts of the pro-peace Israeli left. Some parts of these arguments are deconstructed effectively by Zachary Wales in an op-ed on electronicintifada.net. Wales writes:
But the critical failures of Goldberg’s work stem from two areas: His attempts to legitimize Zionism, an ethnically exclusive colonial project, as a liberal idea; and his omission of the Palestinian right of return, which, according to the vast majority of Palestinians, is the reason there is no peace.
Wales points to the expulsion of nearly 800,000 Palestinians during the 1948 war, and to documented massacres of Palestinian villagers. "Unless population transfer and genocide are the building blocks of liberal society," Wales writes, "Goldberg’s historical premise for sanctifying Zionism is existential at best." A bit dramatic, but the point remains. He goes on:
This rhetorical blunder could not stand on its own without the help of selective fact-checking. Throughout the piece, Goldberg frequently refers to Israel as a Jewish democracy, and states that “Arabs and Jews living inside Israel’s borders are judged by the same set of laws in the same courtrooms.” Goldberg’s careful semantics may be accurate, but his case for liberal democracy is promiscuous.
Wales goes on to enumerate the many discriminatory measures taken against Arabs within Israel, eloquently concluding, "By eliminating the legitimate and empirical arguments against Zionism, Goldberg leaves his readers with few moral conclusions." Indeed, despite inserting himself in the role of defender of the Palestinians against the Jewish zealots of the settlements, a closer reading of Goldberg's article shows evidence of a certain lack of sympathy for the suffering of Palestinians. Before quoting Michael Tarazi's assertion that the settlements highlight the apartheid nature of Israel's occupation, Goldberg writes, "The most farsighted among the Palestinians now understand that settlements are good for their cause." A useful example of discriminatory policy and disregard for international law? Yes. "Good for their cause"? Maybe not "good" in so simple a way as that, seeing as how they directly, and negatively, impact the ability of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza to go about their daily lives.
Near the end of the piece, Goldberg interviews Menachem Froman, a rabbi who lives in Tekoa, one of the illegal settlements in the West Bank. Froman believes that the West Bank should become Palestine, and that he would gladly become a Palestinian citizen if it did. He says: "I’m a realist. I accept reality. I’m not talking about utopia. I accept what I see. There is a Tekoa and a Tuqua." And Goldberg’s editorialized rebuttal: “Froman is naïve to believe that the Palestinians would accept [him].”
In doing so Goldberg not only damns the pro-peace Israeli left as "naive", but also the entire Palestinian population as intolerant Jew-haters (reinforced by his interviews with Sheik Ahmed Yassin and Dr. Abdel Aziz Rantisi of Hamas). Nowhere in the article does Goldberg give a Palestinian peacenik even the short shrift he gives Menachem Froman. For me, even as the article succeeds in exposing the settlements for what they are (a menace II society, whether Israeli or Palestinian), it fails in forcing the settlement issue into Goldberg's rigid framework of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

(My apologies for such a long post, I hope a few people made it all the way through.)


I'm sorry for being intrusive in to your blog. But I am Melissa and I am a mother of two that is just trying to get out of an incredible financial debt. See my hubby is away in Iraq trying to protect this great country that we live in, and I am at home with our two kids telling bill collectors please be patiant. When my husband returns from war we will beable to catch up on our payments. We have already had are 2001 Ford repossessed from the bank, and are now down to a 83 buick that is rusted from front to back and the heater don't work, and tire tax is due in November.

I'm not asking for your pitty because we got our ownselfs into this mess but we would love you and thank you in our prayers if you would just keep this link on your blog for others to view.

God Bless You.

Melissa K. W.
To see my family view this page. My Family

Full Software Download - Get full access to thousands of applications!

Restore, Fix & Clean Up Your Registry Files and Errors in Windows. Does your PC crash, is your system running slow or are you receiving regular error messages? This program will scan your system registry and hard drive for invalid file and system references for free. These invalid references cause system instability, PC errors, constant crashes, and general system slowdowns.

XoftSpy - The Latest in Anti-Spyware & Adware Technology
I like the page you have here. Check mine out data recovery specialist
Link to my site and enjoy untethered information relaiting to Date Loss on computers.
data recovery service software
I too hate spyware and adware and am always searching for free anti adware related information. The more people around the world who become aware of free anti adware the better.
Hi Blogger, I found your blog quite informative.
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my tax increment financing site.
Have a great week!
Great blog, keep up the good work. If you get a chance check out my site.remove adware
Hey, just out surfing and found your blog. It wasn't what I was looking for but I did enjoy reading it. If you want to check out my site go to fix computer error
Latest news. Viagra, cialis

However mean your gold in wow life is,buy wow gold meet it and live it ;wow gold cheap do not shun it and call it hard names.It is not so bad as you are.It looks poorest when you are richest.The fault-finder will find faults in paradise.wow gold kaufen love your life,poor as it is.maple meso You may perhaps have some pleasant,thrilling,maplestory power leveling glorious hourss,even in a poor-house.The setting sun is reflected from the windows of the alms-house as brightly as from the rich man's abode;the snow melts before its door as early in the spring.sell wow gold I do not see but a quiet mind may live as contentedly there,cheap mesos and have as cheering thoughts,as in a palace.The town's poor seem to me often to live the most independent lives of any.May be they are simply great enough to billig wow gold receive without misgiving.Most think that they are above being supported by the town;powerlevel but it often happens that buy maplestory mesos they are not above supporting themselves by dishonest means.which should be more disreputable.Cultivate poverty like a garden herb,like sage.Do not trouble wow powerleveln yourself much to get new things,maple mesos whether clothes or friends,Turn the old,archlord power leveling return to them.Things do not change;we change.Sell your clothes and keep your thoughts.
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?